Puppet Pals In Big Trouble is a story arc in Puppet Pals 2. In this story, the characters have to go find somewhere else to use as a stage.

Plot

We start off with Shakespeare introducing everyone to another episode of his in-universe show, “Shakespeare and Friends’ Greatest Hits,” a semi-daily performance compilation of the characters performing gags and tricks, and telling jokes at Shakespeare’s Dinner Theatre. However, before this episode can start, The Sheriff shows up and tells Shakespeare that he can’t use his stage for a week do to an “incident.” Shakespeare states that he forgot and leaves with the others(Little Boy, Little Girl, The Sheriff, Ballerina, and Abe Lincoln). They find the Coliseum and, unaware of its abandoned nature, enter it. Little Boy and Little Girl are separated from the others on Floor B1. Below them in B2, The Sheriff, Ballerina, Abe Lincoln, and Shakespeare are left in complete darkness(Little Boy and Little Girl are too). Little Boy tells Little Girl to dig, but she refuses; Little Boy then says that “people fart in chairs all day that [she] sits in,” leading to a disgusted response from Little Girl, and she ultimately agrees to dig. They dig a tunnel to Floor B2, where the others are waiting. Shakespeare and The Sheriff are on the verge of fighting, but Little boy and Little Girl arrive in time to intervene. Shakespeare sees a light, thinking it’s an exit. Little Boy tries to explain what the “exit” was, but Shakespeare accidentally enters without listening. Little Boy, followed by the others, head to where Shakespeare went. The “exit” turns out to be the Data Dump, a world in the app where deleted stuff ends up at, with big words floating in the sky. The Hypnotist arrives and pushes the Big Red Button to release everyone from the Dump, at the cost of the Puppet Pals 2 universe. As the worlds crumble slowly, Little Boy and the others hurry to Cowboy Town to push the Big Green Button, which ultimately restores the worlds. Little Boy then asks if anyone wants to get some fast food, ending the episode.